[PLUG-TALK] Re: small shotgun?
glen e. p. ropella
gepr at tempusdictum.com
Wed Jul 14 00:18:59 UTC 2004
=><=><= "g" == GLL <guy1656 at ados.com> writes:
g> But here's a new point: What's a 'small shotgun?' Any shotgun
Well, I actually meant small caliber or large gauge. I consider a
.410 to be small.
g> But for home-defense use, a barely-legal unit such as the Mossberg would be
g> ideal. Question: What's your opinion (and others') about using a legally
g> registered class-III weapon for self defense? So, I go to a dealer, see a
g> piece I like, pay for it, have a legal record cleaner than most hippies, go
g> down to the sheriff's dept. chief of police, or the county judge, sign my ATF
g> form-4's, get my fingers dirty on the FD-258,'s do the stupid 'yes I am a US
g> Citizen form' (ATF 5330.20) pay $200 tax, wait 5 months or more, then pick it
g> up from the dealer.
g> Now, is it any more legally dangerous for me to take the same legitimate
g> action with the (legally registered) sawed-off shotgun than it would be with
g> the Mossberg? If not, then perhaps we should be encouraging homeowners to get
g> that 'small shotgun' - followign all the legally loop-de-loops, of course.
g> (and discouraging people from trading in or creating contraband weapons...)
My personal opinion is that a short barrel is better for home defense
than a long barrel.
I wouldn't encourage anyone to buy any gun, actually. If someone wants
a gun, then I'd encourage them to get the right gun for their purpose
(which might include killing innocent people). If they don't already
want a gun, then I would actually discourage them from getting a gun
for home defense.... get an alarm system and some big dogs.... and take
some martial arts classes... [grin]
My original question way back at the start of this thread was:
Should I get a CHL and, thereby, alert the authorities that I have
and carry a gun? Or, should I just carry it without telling anyone
I'm carrying it? (I realize it's illegal.)
The reason for this question is that when we finally do get around to
banning guns (which I'm sure we will as the population continues to
grow and every inch of land is turned into "city"), if I've got a
_license_ of any sort, then the authorities know that I have a gun and
will definitely visit my house looking for them... which will force me
to keep my guns separated into two bins: 1) the ones the gub'ment
knows about and 2) the one they don't. I'll also have to hide bin 2
fairly well.
But, if I don't get any kind of license and buy all my guns privately,
then perhaps they won't come to my house looking for my guns.
Given that context, it makes more sense for people to minimize the
visibility into their private lives and avoid filling out all those
forms you mention.
g> The counter argument here is that the outlaws who are already willing to break
g> a number of state and federal laws by robbing a bank, procuring a stolen car,
g> etc, - are not at all fazed by gun bans.
Well, as the other posts on this topic point out, the statistics on
this are pretty vague, as well. So, I wouldn't be capable of claiming
that either side of the argument is true.
However, it is a _very_ strong argument that if guns are rare, then
gun violence will be rare. And if guns are made illegal, then they
will be rarer than they are when they're legal... UNLESS, they're
simply made to be extremely expensive without making them illegal.
Hummers, billion dollar homes, gilded shoestrings, etc. are all rare;
but not because they're illegal.
So, the essence of the gun-banners' argument remains intact in spite
of the counter argument. And that argument is: The more rare guns
are, the fewer guns will be used in crime or violence.
And there are _many_ ways to make objects rare.... For example, start
a worldwide marketing campaign programming our youth into thinking that
people who own or carry guns are morons or "uncool". That works even
better than making something illegal. Characterize them with Confederate
battle flags, trailer homes, a lack of teeth, and a tendency to watch
"reality tv", and you've immediately got the attention of 90% of our
population. The campaign would be wildly successful... much more so
than the current tobacco or marijuana campaigns. [ugh]
g> Did you know that there was abank job done in CANADA in the 70's in which the
g> perps uses a sawed-off 20MM (!!!) to blow the hinges off the vault?!? They
g> created a make-shif supressor out of a 55-gal oil drum (ooo, another
g> class-iii violation in the US.) They were caught because even a supressed
g> 20MM was loud enough to draw attention to themselves.
_Very_ cool story! No, I didn't know that.
--
glen e. p. ropella =><= Hail Eris!
H: 503.630.4505 http://www.ropella.net/~gepr
M: 971.219.3846 http://www.tempusdictum.com
More information about the PLUG-talk
mailing list