[PLUG-TALK] Re: [PLUG] reply-to curiosity...

Keith Lofstrom keithl at kl-ic.com
Wed Aug 15 16:10:56 UTC 2007


I am replying on PLUG-TALK, because this is veering away from a
discussion about Linux and into a discussion about preferences.

On Wed, Aug 15, 2007 at 02:05:27AM -0700, Kris wrote:
> Kris wrote:
> > I say keep it the way it is.  At a minimum you get a chuckle out of a private
> > reply.  At a maximum you get a glimpse into someone's true intentions and
> > personality.  Occasionally you get an accidental phone # into the archives,
> > which the admin should be able to help with.
> 
> Damn.  The IETF stepped in in 2001 to settle this with RFC 2822.  I love RFCs.
> So yeah, down with Reply-To munging and up with RFC 2369 (List-Post header)! ;)
> 
> http://woozle.org/~neale/papers/reply-to-still-harmful

Standards are useful, but they are neither government or natural laws. 
In this case, they represent the opinions of that tiny subset of
people that show up at IETF meetings.  Their technical insights are
vital.  Their opinions on voluntary human behavior are no more
interesting than the opinions of any other small subset of unelected
people.  I say this as an active member in standards organizations,
who has watched the group dynamics and the standards that result. 
An awful lot of petty tyrants show up at these meetings.

What shows up in your inbox can have any damned format permitted by
SMTP, and that includes misleading or fraudulent REPLY-TO lines.  
Imposing particular behaviors on this or that mailing list will not
magically make REPLY-TO trustworthy, and writing RFCs about REPLY-TO
does not eliminate any of the human effort needed to intelligently
choose a response to an incoming email.

This argument is about the default behavior of three bits of software -
the mail program used to send to the list, the list program, and the
receiving mail program.  The list mailer is automatic, but the sending
and receiving programs are operated by allegedly intelligent humans.
Default behaviors mean that the human operators don't have to use that
intelligence and actually think as much about what happens with the
mail they send.  And that is very, very WRONG.

In the Real World(tm), not thinking about who you are talking to and
what you are saying can result in a beating (and yes, there are laws
related to that, but you would be a fool to rely on them).  One of the
big problems with email is that people do not apply the same diligence
and self control that they do in F2F communication.  The choice of who
to send to should always be considered before sending out an email,
and one of the worst features of most mailers is automatic "reply-to" 
without subsequent verification.  IMHO, mailers should always present
a list of recipients, and ask "are you sure" before sending, perhaps
including a cognitive impairment test.  Spelling and grammar checks
would be nice, too.  Those that bypass the checking self-identify as
idiots, and that is nice for recipients to know.

Instead of imposing global restrictions on the behavior of groups using
mailing lists, it is far better to teach people to ALWAYS check the
"TO" line, and ALWAYS check the "SUBJECT" line,  and ALWAYS edit out
extraneous message content, and ALWAYS think about the message content
from the viewpoint of the person reading it.  Making thoughtless
communication easier should not be encouraged by software and standards.

In other words, THINK, dammit!  

Keith

-- 
Keith Lofstrom          keithl at keithl.com         Voice (503)-520-1993
KLIC --- Keith Lofstrom Integrated Circuits --- "Your Ideas in Silicon"
Design Contracting in Bipolar and CMOS - Analog, Digital, and Scan ICs



More information about the PLUG-talk mailing list